UK time is: 00:06:00
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

VB Weekend Winners and Losers



Jesus Christ is it Monday morning again already?! Ah well, on we go as we look back on a difficult month for a Blackburn Rovers fan, a month that has seen us take on three of the big boys away from home and of course, the derby vs Burnley.

A real mixed month, plenty of positives and plenty of things to work on. Lets just be glad that we have got three of the most difficult fixtures all season out of the way already.

Anyway, Saturday evening at Man United from an optimists point of view was an improved showing from Stamford Bridge - players willing to close down, fight for the team and follow team orders.

From a pessimistic angle it was a Rovers performance that lacked invention and was merely an attempt to stay in the game as long as possible.

Where do I sit? On the fence actually... we were somewhere i the middle of the two polars I described. But I am pleased we are heading into a month where lots of points are achievable and Rovers home form is very good. Its just the away stuff that needs to pick up, but I am confident it will.

Anyway, who's done what, where, when and how this weekend?

WINNERS

GAEL GIVET - Super stuff at the theatre of dreams on Saturday from the Frenchman. He was stuck out in the left back spot where he is equally as comfortable as in the centre and stuck to his task admirably.

He kept Valencia reasonably quiet and put in at least three stunning blocks to thwart the United onslaught. One in particular from Dimitar Berbatov was top draw (I refuse to use the term 'world class' as it really doesn't mean a single thing!).

Next week as we move back to Ewood we may have stumbled across our prefered back four which leads me onto...

PASCAL CHIMBONDA - His first game for Rovers in his first choice right back spot was a super shift and shows why Sam spent wisely to bring him here. Fair enough he was marking the tricky but ultimately ineffective Nani but he ran a tight ship, covered everything with pace and didn't put a foot wrong in the tackle.

For me, the standout performer on Saturday and looking a snip and an inspired buy at 2 million.

A back four of Chimbonda, Samba, Nelsen, Givet looks the way forward to me.

PAUL ROBINSON - The nightmare of last week has been banished.

He has been castigated in the media for not being able to handle long range shots after letting a strong but aimless Michael Essien effort in at Chelsea due to poor positioning and there were concerns his confidence would be shattered.

His response was great. Looked assured at all times and commanded his area to restore parity on what has been a tough week for Paul.

People will still say things like 'hey, he conceded five at Chelsea and six at Arsenal so he's still rubbish!'. But people who have said that are ignorant fools who are on a witch hunt. Look at the goals and conceded and tell me how many Paul could have kept out (bar the Essien one), the answer rhymes with hero and is a circular number. It's mainly poor defensive work that has exposed Englands' Number One and if anything is it wasnt for some great stops for Robinson, things could have been a lot worse.

Anyway, back to Manchester and smart stops from Berbatov twice, Rooney, Carrick and Nani was the sum of his efforts and the two goals that beat him were unstoppable by anyones standards.

For a month where he has shifted 15 goals, Robbo can take a suprising amount of confidence.

LOSERS

KEITH ANDREWS - How long do we have to put up with these anonymous performances? I forgot he was playing for about 40 minutes on Saturday, Steven N'Zonzi had to tackle and battle for two people. Keith's sole job seemed to be to get the ball and make sure United got the ball back!

We could have played Emerton in Andrews spot, and played Hoilett on left wing, that would have been my ploy to get more presence in the centre of midfield.

I like Keith, unlike others I have backed him but he is out of his depth against this calibre of opposition.

MORTEN GAMST PEDERSEN - After a bright start to the season, it looks an all to familiar story for Morten.

In patches he looked like he had purpose on the ball when he came on but it petered out to nothing. Crosses were poor, losing possession and not getting his head up to find options to pass to.

It may have been the standard of player he was up against but Morten needs to step on the gas in November because Brett, Junior and I imagine Van Heerden are breathing down his neck.

EL HADJI DIOUF - When the going gets tough, instead of the snarling, work happy Diouf that normally turns up was again replaced by the diving, complaing Diouf that turned up against Chelsea.

Again, I know it frustrating when you are playing against the best players there are (and John O'Shea)but it doesn't reflect well and shows a certain air of desperation when all you can do is shout at the ref when things don't go your way.

All in all, I speak for all this weeks 'losers' when I say there is plenty for them to work on this week.
The Journalist

Writer: Mikey Delap Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday November 2 2009

Time: 9:29AM

Your Comments

as always keep the dream alive and keep the comments coming!
Mikey Delap
Last season i defended Keith, he needed time to settle, Ince obviously saw something in him, he had a few good performances towards the end of the season which seemed to give him confidence! I can't defend him any longer, i couldn't watch the match on Saturday but i listened to it on Radio Lancs and he sounded woeful, all the reports i have read say he was awful, and this is just another poor performance in a long line. He got booed on Tuesday night when he came on against Posh,people are just getting tired of him,having someonje like Steven N'Zonzi come in and adapt so quickly just shows him up!! He is not good enough i am affraid!
bennipoo
nice again mikey really enjoy this segment. agree with all that, particularly gamst. he was absolutely shocking
retroflair31
OK one thing i dont get is samba should have been a winner he was clearing everything coming into the box. This has to be the new back four i have already mentioned it in one of the forums but no one listened to me ill be dissapointed if we dont go with this against pompey.............I agree bennipo i rated andrews last season but this season hes been pretty crap id put grella in any day and i dont like grella(sorry sas)
aadil4rovers
sorry aadil must of missed that! I agree with what you are saying but Sas will not be happy lol!
Mikey Delap
Curious about Andrews - BSA and N Ireland clearly rate him but I agree - he's a good utility player but not the match winner that we need - is he just holding the fort until Reid is fully fit? The trouble with MGP is that you never know when he's going to pop up and win a match - the goal against Peterborough was brilliant - then at Utd??? I was surprised that Junior didn't get a run out - he covers at the back and yet has the speed to take the attack to the opposition - I think he would have been useful at Old Trafford.
YORK ROVER
Samba - great on Saturday but I don't think he was fully fit - did anyone notice that he seemed to be limping in the build up to the second goal (cramp?) - otherwise he would have been up with play and might even have cut out the cross to Rooney?
YORK ROVER
hey hey...enough grella bashing lol...he has been good this season! he will be back for the pompey game holding that midfield.....
sasman
I'm another who has been willing to give Andrews time and patience but the dude isn't good enough and MGP hasn't been good enough (a few moments aside) for a long time now so it's time for both to be shipped out of the side and maybe out of the squad!! Diouf needs to play more football and less dramatics. The winners were winners for a reason, and rightly so.
Walker
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Walker 22
2. dallydally 15
3. roverjoy 9
4. rovers2011 5
5. rover50 2
6. felling2 2
7. archery 2
8. Rye of the Rovers 1

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
5. Brentford 21 11 4 6 7 37
6. Watford 21 10 5 6 15 35
7. Norwich 21 9 6 6 11 33
8. Blackburn 21 8 7 6 1 31
9. Forest 21 7 9 5 5 30
10. Charlton 21 6 12 3 1 30
11. Cardiff 21 8 6 7 0 30

Breaking League News

Malky Mackay Speaks About The 'Football Truce'
Wigan : 19/12/2014 23:50:00
The Derby Preview
Norwich : 19/12/2014 23:22:00
What The Bosses Say - Latics v Rotherham United
Wigan : 19/12/2014 22:47:00
Early Team News - Latics v Rotherham United
Wigan : 19/12/2014 22:17:00
Millwall : 19/12/2014 21:39:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Blackburn v Charlton
Suggested By:  Site Staff
Blackburn win 56%
Draw 22%
Charlton win 22%