UK time is: 21:06:30
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Is Benni a "Big Game" Player?!?!

Clint has raised the question as to whether or not Blackburn Rovers forward Benni McCarthy is a "big game" player?

BEFORE you jump to conclusions (or indeed jump down his throat!) take a look at what Clint had to say...

I know Benni McCarthy has scored 12/13 Premiership goals and some crackers but just how many have been against the "bigger" clubs? I'm beginning to believe that he's not a big game player, unfairly maybe, but the thought has just come into my head.

Let's look at Benni's record - (This is written before the Watford game) He's scored 13 goals in 30 League matches, not a bad strike rate at almost a goal every other game. Half of these, well 6 have come against teams in the top eight/nine, teams vying for Europe (2 vs. Liverpool, 2 vs. Bolton, 1 vs. Everton and 1 vs. Reading - two of these were penalties vs. Bolton) the rest have come against "lower teams". In the FA Cup he has 3 goals in 5 ties (1 vs. Arsenal, 1 vs. Everton - Top teams), UEFA Cup 3 goals in 8 ties (2 vs. Salzburg, 1 vs. Basel).

So in terms of goals against the top nine he has six goals 17 games (we still have Tottenham Hotspur and Reading to play again), the top four alone two in eight… (although he wasn't available to feature in all eight, certain he missed Arsenal home and away, through injury and suspension?)

Clint adds:

A very good strike rate that's not in doubt for his first season in England and I'm not doubting his contribution to the team but only really Liverpool I would consider one of the top teams (the top team he's scored again in the league). Now I know he did score against the Gunners in the cup but I feel he's not doing it against teams like Manchester Utd, Chelsea and Arsenal in the league. Now the team has played well against these three teams in the league this year without winning, my question is, is Benni a big game player??

I think he goes missing at times when we need him to score in important matches, like the Bayer Leverkusen game when Rovers were all over them and just didn't score - 2nd leg. But I do believe that a player with his ability and scoring record he should be more of a threat against the big boys, after all that's why he was brought in!

THIS ARTICLE WAS WRITTEN USING CLINT'S THOUGHTS.

So is Benni a big game player? Have we been disappointed by his contribution against the bigger sides? You know what you have to do…


Don't forget "Walkerbout" Sunday Evening's in the forum between 6pm & 8pm - For more information click here. It will return on Sunday 22nd April, topics are up to you so click here.

But don't forget the forum itself, you can talk about whatever you want there and YOU decide what it is! Forum Link.

Why should you sign up to Vital Blackburn? - click here and you'll find out!




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Walker Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Thursday April 19 2007

Time: 1:05AM

Your Comments

You would think a player of benni's quality and experience of the BIGGEST of big games would be just that (a big game player) but I do see Clint's point. When you look at things against the bigger sides League and Cup he has gone missing at times, so not quite sure where I stand on it. BUT I also see it this way how many players really come to the party against the big boys though?!?! That is why they generally are big boys. You can't just look at the goals and contribution of Benni; you have to look at it in detail as Clint has so from the big game point of view it is a disappointing return on an otherwise tremendous first season in England. Some players take ALONG time to adapt to the Premiership, but he hasn't really. I feel next season will see him even better so this big game mentality will almost certainly be there.
Hughes Da Man
I think we are being a little harsh. The big game players are always the workhorses of which Benni not renowned for being. But look at the Liverpool game for evidence of what he can do... one chance... on goal... thats why he is there.
MikeyGamst
It does seem harsh and Benni has done a great job but if you stop and think about it and it maybe isn't as harsh as it seems?!?! He's adapted BRILLIANTLY to the Premiership, IF he goes missng at times next season against these teams then I think we really can be questioning this big game mentality, although I can understand why we would now as I say the real test will be next season.
Hughes Da Man
im not puttin Benni into a witch-hunt by any means lads, i just think that sometimes and only sometimes he can go missing, I dont know if it that the bigger claubs have better defenders and mark him better than the rest or he just dosnt play well against these supposed better players, im not wording this right I know but I hope someone else kinda know's wot im on about
Clint
I'm pretty sure I get you Clint and can see (as I've said) what you mean. Let's see how he stands up to these challenges next season.
Hughes Da Man
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Articles

Morecambe extend Edwards loan (Thursday April 24 2014)

Dunn to play waiting game (Thursday April 24 2014)

Rovers disappoint again (Friday April 18 2014)

Rovers expecting DJ help (Thursday April 17 2014)

Marshall aiming for early return (Wednesday April 16 2014)

Archived Articles

List All Vital Blackburn Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
7. Brighton 44 17 15 12 12 66
8. Forest 44 16 17 11 7 65
9. Ipswich 44 17 14 13 6 65
10. Blackburn 44 16 16 12 5 64
11. Bournemouth 44 17 12 15 -1 63
12. Watford 43 15 15 13 17 60
13. Middlesbrough 44 14 16 14 7 58

Breaking League News

McDermott - I have never seen anything like it
» Leeds Utd : 24/04/2014 21:02:00
Morecambe extend Edwards loan
» Blackburn : 24/04/2014 20:08:00
LUFC Kenny ready to quit Elland Road
» Leeds Utd : 24/04/2014 20:00:00
Owls recall McCabe from Pompey loan
» Sheff Wed : 24/04/2014 18:48:00
Martin Happy With Play-Offs
» Derby County : 24/04/2014 15:00:00
Cherries host Forest
» Bournemouth : 24/04/2014 14:49:00
Prutton weighing up playing options
» Sheff Wed : 24/04/2014 13:39:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Robbo for England? (again)
Suggested By:  VB Admin
Yes, as back up - why not? 55%
No, his time has been and gone 45%