UK time is: 00:27:04
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Penalties-What should we do?

Saturday saw Blackburn Rovers awarded their first penalty of the season but conceded two, which now makes it four penalties conceded in four fixtures. Despite being involved in five penalty decisions only one has been scored (and that was only just as Brad Friedel got a strong hand on Frank Lampard`s penalty in the defeat to Chelsea).

The main issue here is not focusing on what is going wrong at the back, as I strongly believe we have seen four of the softest penalties we will see all season awarded against us, but on who should be taking our penalties and why was Lucas Neill stepping up anyway?

It is well documented that Neill has ambitions away from the club emulating from his refusal to sign a new contract and his vocal agent. Despite this, Mark Hughes continues to choose him as the captain and, as it would appear, choose him as the chief penalty-taker as well.

Everyone knows what Neill is capable of and he has continued to look solid if not a tad distracted as well early on this season. Whereas many are happy with him continuing as captain in the absence of Ryan Nelsen, it seems odd that he has assumed penalty responsibilities as well. On Saturday against Sheffield United Neill saw his penalty saved after pulling rank on new-boy Benni McCarthy.

It was McCarthy who won the penalty, rather contentiously I may add, and he seemed confident of taking it. However, Neill was soon in the opposition penalty area with the ball in his hand. After a brief conversation with McCarthy, Neill put the ball down and McCarthy trudged out of the area. We all know the outcome.

The debate here is whether or not McCarthy would have been more suitable to take the penalty. He is after all our main marksman. Would it not serve the team better if one of our forwards were stepping up? Strikers thrive on confidence; we only have to look at the example of Andy Johnson a couple of years ago who slotted home ten penalties in his twenty-one goal haul. I have even heard suggestions claiming Francis Jeffers would have been more suitable in a bid to build up his confidence.

In our previous couple of seasons we have had four different penalty takers: Paul Dickov, Robbie Savage, Craig Bellamy and Lucas Neill. Savage missed his and hasn`t taken one since. Bellamy scored his only penalty but it was assumed Dickov was the clubs leading penalty-taker. Indeed he only missed one of his penalties and this was Neill`s first miss.

It appears we have more success when our front-men, confidence players, are taking penalties.

What do people think on this subject who would you have taking penalties for Rovers this season? Keep an eye out for a poll on this matter over the weekend but have your say now.

CLICK HERE - For Why You Should Sign Up To Vital Blackburn




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!


Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Roversman Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Tuesday September 12 2006

Time: 7:04PM

Your Comments

As we know at Rovers we don't often get penalties awarded for us so it is majorly important that we don't miss any. I do trust Neill but feel that it would be better for our frontmen to be taking them. What do people think?
roversman
Looks like Neill took the leadership responsabilities quite literally to his head! He can strike a ball, but not the penalty taker for me. Jeffers can take them, Benni surely, Roberts isn't bad either. Maybe Steven Reid could be a decent shout?
Hughes Da Man
With the forwards you've got I would've thought one of them should be your regular taker.
sandgroanun
You would think, Neill obviously felt differently! Would be surprised to see him step up again tomorrow if Rovers get one in Austria?
Hughes Da Man
I think Benni will be the man to take them from now on. We saw how confident he is at the weekend and Neill won't have much of a case anymore. However, as long as they go in I don't mind who is taking them!
roversman
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Articles

Rovers disappoint again (Friday April 18 2014)

Rovers expecting DJ help (Thursday April 17 2014)

Marshall aiming for early return (Wednesday April 16 2014)

Millwall set to end Campbell loan (Thursday April 10 2014)

Bowyer delighted with Rovers (Wednesday April 9 2014)

Archived Articles

List All Vital Blackburn Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
8. Ipswich 43 17 13 13 6 64
9. Forest 43 15 17 11 5 62
10. Bournemouth 43 17 11 15 -1 62
11. Blackburn 43 15 16 12 3 61
12. Watford 42 15 15 12 18 60
13. Middlesbrough 43 14 16 13 9 58
14. Bolton 43 13 16 14 -2 55

Breaking League News

Edwards - We Need Semi Final Atmopshere
Yeovil : 19/04/2014 23:15:00
Johnson Delighted With Continued Fight
Yeovil : 19/04/2014 23:03:00
Pearson - Hails Discipline
Leicester City : 19/04/2014 22:38:00
Holloway Proud After Middlesbrough Display
Millwall : 19/04/2014 22:22:00
We need to change - Karanka
Middlesbrough : 19/04/2014 22:12:00
McCarthy - Missed Opportunities
Ipswich : 19/04/2014 22:11:00
Boro run ends
Middlesbrough : 19/04/2014 22:00:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Robbo for England? (again)
Suggested By:  VB Admin
Yes, as back up - why not? 56%
No, his time has been and gone 44%