UK time is: 14:43:31
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Keith Andrews for Alan Smith swap?

Newcastle United have enqiured about the availability of Keith Andrews as they look to bolster their midfield for their Championship promotion push.

Rather than the answer of 'oh, please good lord take him' they instead received the answer of 'Can we have Alan Smith in exchange'?

The Sunday Mirror primarily ran with the story but a few others have now joined in the fun. It does seem an interesting proposition and it may well be fictional but to me Alan Smith IS an improvement as the tough tackling midfielder role.

Therefore it wouldn't be a bad thing if we were to get hold of him - he doesn't score a lot (at all in fact) but he has been in fine form for the Geordies this season.

As for Keith, I don't think we will find too many crying if he is sold.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Mikey Delap Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday January 25 2010

Time: 9:07AM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Maybe an improvement, but how much of one? I'm not sure this is where our limited transfer activity should be focused. With Reidy managing to somehow perform a miracle aka play 2 games without picking up an 18 month injury perhaps we already have Keith's replacement?
fransavarese
Report Abuse
25/01/2010 09:25:00

That may be so fran but what about a replacement for our injury prone Aussie Mr Grella who stretches his legs and gets a hamstring or calf strain? Plus if its like for like and no money involved it must be an improvement!!!
Rover_since74
Report Abuse
25/01/2010 10:39:00

Fair point 74. Guess im hoping Grella gets fit and plays but if he doesn't stay fit I'd rather Alan Smith than Andrews came in for him.
fransavarese
Report Abuse
25/01/2010 11:19:00

It may only be a slight improvement but it is still an improvement in my eyes!!
Mikey Delap
Report Abuse
25/01/2010 11:47:00

maybe smith will play up front?
LHrover
Report Abuse
25/01/2010 14:27:00

Smith is a defensive midfielder these days I think LH. He hasn't scored a single goal for Newcastle so best to keep him away from our forward line, they are goal shy enough as it is. I'd rather we kept Keith tbh even if it is just to save some poor sod processing the details of this transfer of one *****e hawk for another. We will have nothing to gain from this, granted not much to lose either.
Durks
Report Abuse
25/01/2010 15:05:00

An improvement perhaps (even if only slight) but Smith's wages would certainly been an "improvement" on our wage bill each month and for that simple reason I'm even less of the opinion it'll happen!!
Walker
Report Abuse
25/01/2010 17:15:00

Maybe he will take a cut to get a better move for him?
Mikey Delap
Report Abuse
25/01/2010 20:26:00

We don't play andrews for goals. His offensive production last season was often a matter of fortuitous circumstance. Trading him for another defensive midfielder is fine in my book. As a defender andrews is weak. I hope Sam and John pull the trigger. A new broom sweeps cleanest.
SoCal Rover
Report Abuse
26/01/2010 01:14:00

Alan Smith> He never scores!!!
JT_daniel
Report Abuse
26/01/2010 07:50:00

id not swap him for anyone, just get him sold and be done wi it
glen9mullan
Report Abuse
27/01/2010 01:45:00

 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Blackburn Rovers Articles

Stats: Blackburn v Fulham (Saturday January 31 2015)

Rovers Preview: Fulham (H) (Saturday January 31 2015)

Rovers Secure Spearing (Saturday January 31 2015)

Stick or twist (Friday January 30 2015)

Team News: Blackburn v Fulham (Friday January 30 2015)

Rovers Revival Must Start Saturday! (Friday January 30 2015)

Bowyer Finally Gets Spearing?? (Friday January 30 2015)

Blackburn MotM Against Derby (Friday January 30 2015)

An Odd Decision!! (Thursday January 29 2015)

Archived Blackburn Rovers Articles

List All Vital Blackburn Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. rover50 1

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
6. Watford 28 14 5 9 23 47
7. Wolves 28 12 9 7 -2 45
8. Norwich 28 12 8 8 16 44
9. Blackburn 28 10 9 9 0 39
10. Sheff Wed 28 9 11 8 -4 38
11. Birmingham 28 9 10 9 -8 37
12. Forest 28 8 10 10 -3 34

Breaking League News

Never Give In - Ipswich 0 Latics 0
Wigan : 01/02/2015 14:37:00
Wolves : 01/02/2015 14:20:00
Reading : 01/02/2015 14:00:00
Celtic looking At Hoolahan?
Norwich : 01/02/2015 13:29:00
Loovens slapped with two-match ban
Sheff Wed : 01/02/2015 13:14:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Fulham MotM
Suggested By:  
Steele 0%
Lowe 0%
Hanley 0%
Kilgallon 0%
Olsson 0%
Marshall 0%
Evans 100%
Spearing 0%
Conway 0%
Rhodes 0%
Brown 0%
Sub:-Taylor 0%
Sub:-Cairney 0%